Advice for my keeper league...

[Cardinals GM (Travis)]

Hey guys, I wanted to get your take. I inherited a keeper league team where I keep 6 players, 2 of which at least must be pitchers. Here is the roster from last year:

Elvis Andrus
Lance Berkman
Adrián Béltre
Adrián González
Matt Joyce
Ian Kinsler
Paul Konerko
Nick Markakis
Seth Smith
Justin Turner
Dan Uggla
Will Venable
Jayson Werth
Matt Wieters
Eric Young

Andrew Bailey
Daniel Bard
Matt Cain
Dillon Gee
Josh Johnson
Justin Masterson
Mark Melancon
Matt Moore
Fernando Salas
José Valverde

Sucks that I can only keep 6 and that two must be pitchers, so these decisions are hard. Here are the scoring categories:

R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OBP, SLG

W, SV, K, HLD, ERA, WHIP, QS

[Cardinals GM (Travis)]

Oh yeah, roster positions:

C
1B
2B
3B
SS
CI
MI
OF
OF
OF
OF
U

SP
SP
SP
RP
RP
P
P
P

[Rockies GM (Alex/Co-Commish)]

Johnson, Moore, kinsler, andrus, weiters, Gonzalez.

[Cardinals GM (Travis)]

Very interesting take. Care to explain?

Cain is tough for me to pass up, he's been super consistent and Johnson has had a lot of injuries including last year.

Konerko has also been super consistent.

[Twins GM (Nathan)]

Depending on how many teams are in the league, I would swap out Wieters and keep Cain.